Important information - investment values and income from investments can go down as well as up, so you may get back less than you invest.

Shares, funds, and exchange-traded funds (ETFs) are some of the most popular investment choices for investors. They’re popular for a variety of different reasons.

But does it really matter which one you choose?

At first glance, they might seem quite similar. However, there are some important differences in how they work, what you're actually investing in and how much control you have.

Here's what you need to know.

  • Refer a friend and you’ll both receive a £100 Amazon.co.uk gift card when they invest £5,000 or more in a qualifying account. T&Cs and exclusions apply. Find out more

What is a share?

If you’ve ever wanted to invest directly in a company, a share can often be a solid choice.

When you buy a share, you're buying a small piece of a company. That makes you a shareholder, meaning you own a part of that business.

Some companies also pay dividends, which are payments to shareholders, usually from company profits. However, these aren't guaranteed.

Shares trade on a stock exchange. This means you can buy and sell them throughout the trading day when the relevant market is open.

The main thing to remember when investing in shares is that you're investing directly in an individual company. If its share price falls, so does the value of your investment. And if the company runs into serious financial difficulties, you could lose some or even all of your money.

That's why relying on one company's shares can be riskier than spreading your money across different investments.

What is a fund?

Rather than investing in one company, what if you wanted to invest in lots of them at once?

That's where a fund comes in.

A fund pools your money alongside money from other investors. It then invests that money in a collection of investments, such as shares, bonds or a mix of both. 

This means you can invest in lots of different assets without having to buy each one yourself. This is known as diversification, which means spreading your money across investments - so you're not relying entirely on one investment.

Funds can be managed in two main ways:

  • Actively managed funds have a fund manager who makes decisions about what to buy and sell. They typically aim to outperform a particular market or achieve another investment objective.
  • Passively managed funds aim to track the performance of a particular market index, such as the FTSE 100, rather than trying to beat it.

Traditional funds, such as unit trusts and open-ended investment companies (OEICs), are usually priced once a day. This means you typically won't know the exact price you'll pay or receive when placing an order.

And while diversification can help reduce risk, it doesn't remove it. Funds can still fall in value if the investments they hold perform poorly.

What is an ETF?

An ETF, or exchange-traded fund, is actually a type of investment fund.

Like traditional funds, ETFs let you invest in a collection of assets through a single investment. For example, an ETF tracking the FTSE 100 could give you exposure to many of the UK's largest listed companies.

But there's one key difference in how they're bought and sold. Unlike traditional funds, ETFs can be bought and sold throughout the trading day, just like shares.

Their prices can also change throughout the day, depending on market conditions.

Most ETFs aim to track an index, meaning they try to follow the performance of a particular market. However, there are also actively managed ETFs, where investment managers make decisions about what the fund holds.

ETFs can offer a straightforward way to spread your money across different investments, although some focus on particular sectors, countries or industries. So, not every ETF will provide the same level of diversification.

And remember, just because you're investing in a collection of assets doesn't mean your investment can't fall in value.

The key differences

  Shares ETFs Funds
What are you investing in? A piece of an individual company A collection of assets A collection of assets
How much diversification do they offer? Offers less diversification as you’re investing in one company per individual share Offers more diversification as ETFs normally spread money across multiple assets Offers more diversification as funds normally spread money across multiple assets
When can you buy and sell? During stock market hours During stock market hours Usually at a daily valuation point
How are they managed? You choose which companies to invest in Usually passive, but can be active Active or passive
What are the costs? Potential dealing fees and taxes Ongoing charges, potential dealing fees and trading costs Ongoing charges and potentially other fees

Shares, ETFs or funds: which is right for you?

There's no single investment that's right for everyone. What works for you will depend on your goals, attitude to risk and how involved you want to be in managing your investments.

That said, here are a few things to think about.

  • If you want to choose individual companies: Shares

Shares might appeal to you if you enjoy researching businesses, following their performance and making your own investment decisions. But remember, relying too heavily on one company could leave you more exposed if things don't go as planned.

  • If you want to spread your money across different investments: ETFs and funds

Both ETFs and traditional funds let you invest in a range of assets without having to choose each one yourself. This can make it easier to spread your risk. But it's worth checking what each fund invests in, as some are more focused than others.

  • If you want flexibility over when you buy and sell: ETFs and shares

ETFs and shares might appeal to you if you'd like the flexibility to trade during stock market hours. You have the ability to see market prices throughout the day and choose when to place your order.

  • If you'd rather leave investment decisions to someone else: Actively managed ETFs and funds

If you don't want to choose individual investments yourself, an actively managed ETF or fund might appeal to you. A professional fund manager makes investment decisions on your behalf - although this normally comes with higher charges than passive investing.

You don't have to choose just one

When it comes to choosing your own investments, there’s a variety of possibilities, and there’s no single right decision. So, shares, ETFs and funds can all form part of your portfolio. 

What matters is understanding what you're investing in and making sure your choices suit your goals. Think about how long you can leave your money invested, the risks you're comfortable taking and the costs involved.

After all, it's not about finding the investment that's best for everyone. It's about finding an approach that works for you.

Share this article

Latest articles

Watch - Week in the markets - 16 November 2026

Bulls, bears and bond yields

Tom Stevenson

How often should I check my investments?

When to check in and when to act

Becks Nunn

Bulls, bears and bond yields

What’s driving your investments this week?

Tom Stevenson