Important information: The value of investments and the income from them can go down as well as up, so you may get back less than you invest.

This article first appeared in the Financial Times

AFTER an exceptional 2021, this year was never going to be an easy ride for investors. With the world’s largest economy, the US, moving towards monetary normalisation, choppier market conditions were to be expected. Add to this a brutal mix of snarled supply chains, rising inflationary pressures, Russia’s war in Ukraine and mounting fears about possible recessionary slowdown, and it’s all made for a humbling experience, for even the most seasoned of investors.

Tech and other growth-oriented companies have sold off in dramatic fashion, while ‘old economy’ companies, like the oil majors and mining stocks are striding ahead. The UK market, a pariah for years, has suddenly become a safe place to see out the storm, while the US (never bet against Uncle Sam) has come off the boil.

The technology-heavy Nasdaq index, seen as a bellwether for growth investors, has fallen nearly 30% from its high in November last year, and 20% in the short time since the end of March. Compare that to a considerably more modest decline of around 10% by the ‘old economy’ stocks of the Dow Jones Industrial Average.

‘Old economy’ stocks outperform high-growth peers

None

Source: Refinitiv, 1.11.21 to 1.6.22, total returns, in USD, rebased to 100.

There are many ways of illustrating the travails of tech stocks so far in 2022, you could, for example, take a look at the performance of £10.84bn investment trust behemoth, Scottish Mortgage, a retail investor favourite and top seller on most fund platforms.

Is the savage fall in the share price a golden opportunity to buy one of the UK’s most successful investment trusts at a bargain price? Or is the reliance on a handful of racy technology names - with positions on MRNA vaccine technology (Moderna), gene sequencing (Illumina), or electric cars (Tesla), reason to pause?

Does the Scottish Mortgage sell-off present a buying opportunity?

None

Source: Refinitiv, 1.6.21 to 1.6.22, share price performance in GBP.

Many technology companies saw a huge acceleration of growth during the pandemic, and investors do need to adjust to a deceleration and in some cases a reversal. Markets arguably over-extrapolated long-term growth from a short-term phenomenon, which pushed valuations too high.

With much of their growth still in the future, these tech darlings are worth less in today’s money when their present value is calculated using higher interest rates. Jam tomorrow is much less attractive than jam today in current conditions.

The counterargument to this is that many of the tech fallers are still profitable and cash-generative businesses, delivering high and sustainable profits growth.

In spite of the precipitous decline in its share price, Scottish Mortgage is less troubled by downside risk than some of its peers, believing that fund managers’ time is better spent finding the next Amazon or Tesla, which can grow to many times their current size. The idea is that the outsized gains it makes on these companies will more than compensate for a stock or two where ambitions aren’t realised.

For long that approach has served it well. And in its favour, it is inconceivable that technological change will become less important in the years that lie ahead. The electric vehicle revolution, the desire to automate, shortages of water, energy and decent housing around the globe, and strategies to tackle climate change all call for more technological innovation.

However, my colleague, Jeremy Podger, manager of the Fidelity Global Special Situations Fund (in which I’ve invested a slice of my husband’s SIPP savings), makes an equally pertinent point, which is simply that tech isn’t the only answer. “There will be many new opportunities in tech over the coming years but equally important will be how non-tech companies internalise technology and use it to their competitive advantage.”

As for the growth versus value debate and the so-called ‘market regime change’, it’s worth noting that growth stocks are still more expensive (against expected near term earnings) than they were five years ago and value stocks are still cheaper than they were. Many growth fund managers have felt the pain this year, but that doesn’t mean we’ll see a shift in their investment process.

You could, as Mr Podger suggests, scoop up some good growth stocks caught up in the market rout, while keeping an eye on the many value stocks that look attractive. “It is one of those times when it appears to be best to start to look for outstanding opportunities in both growth and value camps, rather than trying to hide in the middle ground.”

Others argue that the real story playing out in markets right now is not about value versus growth, but rather between cyclicals and defensives. The two have a great deal of overlap, but not entirely, and that will be the decider this year.

“Rather than trying to catch the bottom in growth stocks, or justify increasing valuations in value, investors might do well to look closely at profitability,” says Alexander Jackson of the Rathbone UK Opportunities Fund. A defensive, quality factor, to help protect against the inevitable shocks that appear at this point in the cycle. (Late, but not the end, in case you were wondering).

High quality names typically lead in periods after activity shocks. This is when stock picking, rather than having to buy an entire index or sector, really comes into its own. Active managers can weight their investments towards the best quality opportunities and pick them up when they are most attractively priced. A passive fund by contrast is compelled to buy the bad alongside the good and the expensive alongside the cheap.

This is true throughout the market cycle, but never more so than when markets are nervous and volatile. At such times, good active managers have a huge competitive advantage. The current environment calls for balance, rather than one-way bets - a blend of re-opening and pandemic winners, pro-cyclical and defensive stocks, reflation and resilient businesses.

So how do investors sift through the stock market wreckage from here? The answer is as simple as it is complex: stock by stock. War, inflation and the threat of recession, are making investors nervous, while the market is trying to position for the risk that central banks get it wrong. It’s the job of the active stock picker to find the right blend of names with enough of a fluffy valuation to help cushion the landing, however, soft or bumpy it might be.

Five year performance

(%)
As at 9 June
2017-2018 2018-2019 2019-2020 2020-2021 2021-2022
Dow Jones 15.0 9.6 7.1 15.4 7.0
Nasdaq 19.7 10.1 36.1 25.8 0.8
Scottish Mortgage PLC 27.1 -2.7 44.5 65.8 -33.9

Past performance is not a reliable indicator of future returns

Source: FE from 9.6.17 to 9.6.22. Total returns in GBP. Excludes charges.

Important information: Investors should note that the views expressed may no longer be current and may have already been acted upon. Overseas investments will be affected by movements in currency exchange rates. Reference to specific securities should not be construed as a recommendation to buy or sell these securities and is included for the purposes of illustration only. Tax treatment on pensions depends on individual circumstances and all tax rules may change in the future. Withdrawals from a pension product will not be possible until you reach age 55 (57 from 2028). This information is not a personal recommendation for any particular investment. If you are unsure about the suitability of an investment you should speak to one of Fidelity’s advisers or an authorised financial adviser of your choice.

Share this article

Latest articles

Will electric cars get cheaper?

Lithium shortages could make electric car buyers think again.


Becks Nunn

Becks Nunn

Fidelity International

Greencoat UK Wind Investment Trust

Renewable energy trusts the chief beneficiaries of the surge in power prices


Nick Sudbury

Nick Sudbury

Investment writer

Watch: Market News Update - 8 August 2022

In this week’s market update: investors struggle to decide if the glass is ha…


Tom Stevenson

Tom Stevenson

Fidelity International