Important information: The value of investments and the income from them can go down as well as up, so you may get back less than you invest.

This article first appeared in the Telegraph

WHAT we think about the price of an asset largely reflects whether we are a buyer or a seller of it. Most of us don’t have barrels of crude lying around but we do need to put fuel in our cars. We’re naturally inclined, therefore, to think the oil price is too high. On the other hand, most people of my age live in our own homes so we’re pretty relaxed about house price inflation. Our children may not be. It all depends on which end of the telescope you’re looking through.

The stock market is a curious hybrid from this perspective. Many of us are both buyers and sellers of financial assets. We are likely to own a portfolio of shares and bonds in our pensions or other savings but, if we are still working, we are probably also looking to add to our investments. Looking at what we already own, we want the market to be high. From the point of view of the investments we wish to buy, we’d prefer it to be lower.

As the US stock market dips into bear market territory this week - down more than 20% from its recent high - we are, understandably, conflicted. But you wouldn’t know it from the media’s market coverage, which is written from the perspective of people who already own assets. A fall in the market tends to be presented as a bad thing. But it could just as easily be seen as an opportunity.

This opportunity is potentially even greater than the headlines suggest. The S&P 500 may be 20% lower, but the Nasdaq index is 30% off its peak. Both are averages, and there are plenty of individual shares trading at much greater discounts than these to their recent highs. Parts of the market are starting to look like a very interesting contrarian opportunity.

To get a sense of its scale, I ranked the 800 or so US shares that you can trade on our UK investment platform according to their performance over the past six months. Half of them, around 400 have fallen by more than the S&P 500 index so far this year. There are currently 140 trading 40% or more below their recent peak. About 90 stocks are down more than 50%. Just since January, in other words, they have halved in value, or worse.

These are not small or obscure stocks that you have not heard of. The household names that you can buy for less than half what you would have paid last Christmas include: Facebook-owner Meta (down 51%), Covid vaccine maker Moderna (57% down), payment systems giant PayPal (a 60% discount), Netflix (72% lower) and crypto platform Coinbase (down 79%).

Needless to say, the fact that a share has fallen is no guarantee that it is cheap, merely that it is cheaper than it was. True contrarian investing is not just ferreting around in the rubbish bins for what other investors aren’t interested in. The reason most investors are not contrarians is that it is hard work. Listing the shares that have underperformed is the easy bit. Working out whether the fall is an over-reaction is harder.

Hard but essential. Because a share that has fallen by 50% can still fall by another 100%. There is very often a good reason why a share has fallen out of favour. And it is not always evident in the published data. My initial glance at the 17 shares that made my list of out of favour household names, revealed only three which could not show both rising revenues and profits (or falling losses). The market is famously a discounting mechanism, pricing in the future. The recent falls in these share prices are telling us to take this growth with a pinch of salt.

But history suggests that price drops on this sort of scale are rare and will in time deliver some fantastic rebounds. Markets over-react in both directions because, while share prices are determined in the long run by fundamentals, in the shorter term they can diverge far from them. Investors were probably much too optimistic during the pandemic, in an environment of persistently low interest rates. And they are probably much too pessimistic today as growth slows and financial conditions tighten.

The case for contrarian investing is strong. Bubbles and panics are an unavoidable feature of stock markets. Deep-seated cognitive biases mean investors are particularly prone to major decision-making errors. We over-emphasise the importance of negative events, we extrapolate the recent past and we anchor on earlier price levels. We assign the wrong probabilities to events, suffer from over-confidence, are influenced by group dynamics and fall victim to the contagion of ideas. The list of our mental shortcomings as investors is endless.

And the consequence of the market’s overshoots is that a systematic contrarian approach, applied consistently over time, can deliver outperformance. Buying the cheapest stocks, whether measured against earnings, cashflow, book value or dividends will pay off in the long run. If we can find the stomach to do it. It’s a great deal easier to say it than to do it.

So, I don’t know whether Pinterest (down 52%), Under Armour (off 57%), Peloton (76% down) and Crocs (68% below its peak) will turn out to be good investments. I suspect that some will and some won’t. But I would be very surprised if the anxiety seeping through the rest of the market this week has not already been well and truly priced into a basket of the most friendless stocks.

Important information: Investors should note that the views expressed may no longer be current and may have already been acted upon. Overseas investments will be affected by movements in currency exchange rates. Reference to specific securities should not be construed as a recommendation to buy or sell these securities and is included for the purposes of illustration only. This information is not a personal recommendation for any particular investment. If you are unsure about the suitability of an investment you should speak to one of Fidelity’s advisers or an authorised financial adviser of your choice.

Share this article

Latest articles

Will electric cars get cheaper?

Lithium shortages could make electric car buyers think again.


Becks Nunn

Becks Nunn

Fidelity International

Greencoat UK Wind Investment Trust

Renewable energy trusts the chief beneficiaries of the surge in power prices


Nick Sudbury

Nick Sudbury

Investment writer

Watch: Market News Update - 8 August 2022

In this week’s market update: investors struggle to decide if the glass is ha…


Tom Stevenson

Tom Stevenson

Fidelity International